The GREAT Commission
EARLY CHRISTIAN THEOLOGY & WITNESS
JUSTIN MARTYR
The Word Worth Dying For
Christ, reason, worship and the courage of conviction
The Christian “Atheist”?
A theological portrait grounded in the surviving sources

The Confession That Confronted an Empire
Justin Martyr did not exchange reason for faith; far from it he came to believe that reason had a name: Jesus Christ. That conviction transformed a born and bred pagan philosophical seeker into a Christian teacher, a defender of the Church, and finally a condemned man. Born around AD 100 at Flavia Neapolis in Roman Palestine, he died in Rome around AD 165 because he would not sacrifice to the gods – an demonstrative ‘atheist’ by Roman religious reasoning. His life joined three things too easily separated: the pursuit of truth, the worship of God, and the courage to obey. [1]
The charge of “atheism” exposes the theological heart of the conflict. Justin rejected Rome’s gods precisely because he worshipped the Creator. He could therefore concede that Christians were atheists towards those supposed deities while firmly denying that they were godless. Christianity was not the absence of worship. It was the refusal to give worship to anything unworthy of God. [3, chs. 5–6]
This limited portrait reads Justin sympathetically as a Christian thinker an apologist, while distinguishing his own claims from independently established history. His conversion narrative is literary, his theology predates later creeds, and his polemics require scrutiny. A strong theological account needs those qualifications: conviction is not strengthened by embellishment or exaggeration. [1]
1 | Conversion: The Mind Brought to Prayer
Justin’s philosophical education was a search for God, not merely a taste for clever argument. In the opening of the Dialogue with Trypho, he describes disappointment with a Stoic who could not advance his knowledge of God, a Peripatetic preoccupied with fees, and a Pythagorean who required preliminary mathematical and musical studies. Platonism, however, initially thrilled him. Contemplation of immaterial realities seemed to give his mind wings. Christianity did not interrupt a wholly empty intellectual life; it challenged an intellectual confidence he had begun to enjoy. [2, ch. 2]
In Justin’s narrative, an elderly stranger near the sea questioned that confidence. Could human contemplation reach God unaided? Was the soul divine in itself, or dependent upon God for life? The stranger directed him towards the Jewish prophets who spoke by the divine Spirit, and to explore the claim that Jesus Christ is Lord. He told him to pray that the gates of light would be opened. Knowledge of God required more than intellectual ascent: it required God’s self-disclosure. [2, chs. 3–7]
2 | The Logos: The Truth Is Someone
The organising centre of Justin’s thought is the Logos: God’s Word or Reason. Jesus was not simply a teacher who offered useful ideas about God. Justin confessed him as the pre-existent Son through whom God ordered all things, who became human for our salvation. The universal reach of divine reason and the particular history of Jesus belonged together. [4, chs. 6, 10, 13]
That claim gave Justin a way to appreciate philosophy without making Christ merely one philosopher among others. Thinkers could grasp partial truths because humanity participated in the Logos. But the Word himself, not simply a fragment of insight, had appeared in Christ. Justin therefore wrote: “Whatever things were rightly said among all men, are the property of us Christians.” He was not saying that all religions were equally true. He was claiming that every genuine truth ultimately belonged to Christ. Thus, the echoing adage so frequently used today in Christian circles… “All Truth is God’s Truth.” [4, chs. 8–10, 13]
The resulting posture was neither cultural surrender nor intellectual retreat. Christians could recognise truth in their neighbours’ thought, expose contradictions, and call people towards the fuller revelation they believed Christ supplied. Justin’s lasting contribution was not the elimination of every philosophical difficulty. It was a public model of Christian engagement in which confidence in Christ made serious conversation possible. [1; 4, ch. 13]
3 | Incarnation and Salvation: More Than Moral Improvement
Justin’s Christianity cannot be reduced to admiration for Jesus’ ethics. He confessed that the Son became human, was crucified under Pontius Pilate, rose from the dead, and ascended into heaven. The incarnation was directed towards the conversion and restoration of humanity. Salvation involved God acting for people, not merely people improving themselves. [3, chs. 13, 21–23]
His Second Apology connects the Word’s sharing of human suffering with human healing. In the Dialogue, he interprets Isaiah’s suffering servant through the death of Christ and speaks of purification through faith in Christ’s blood. These passages show that the philosopher’s Christ was also a saving Christ. Jesus enlightened the mind, but he also dealt with sin. [4, ch. 13; 2, ch. 13]
Justin does not set out a single systematic theory of atonement using later theological categories. His language draws together teaching, deliverance, forgiveness, sacrifice, and healing. It is more accurate to preserve that range than to make him an early spokesman for one later denominational system. [1; 2, ch. 13; 4, chs. 6, 13]
4 | Father, Son and Spirit: Theology Before the Creeds
Justin’s writings place the Father, the Son, and the prophetic Spirit within Christian confession and worship. He identifies Jesus as the Son of the true God and insists that Christian reverence for him is reasonable. This is important testimony to devotion to Christ in the second century, well before the later ecumenical councils. [3, chs. 6, 13]
Yet Justin should not be made to speak as though he had already adopted the precise formulations of Nicaea. He describes the Son in “second place” and the Spirit in “third,” and his account contains subordinating language, more a ‘hierarchical’ form of Trinitarianism. The relationship between his formulations and later orthodoxy requires careful historical interpretation. His testimony is powerful precisely when allowed to remain second-century testimony. [3, ch. 13; 1]
The theological lesson is not that doctrine was unimportant before the creeds. It is that Christians were already trying to articulate how the Creator, the incarnate Son, and the inspiring Spirit belonged within their worship of the one God. Justin gives us access to that work in progress. [1]
5 | The Church: Word, Water, Table and Mercy
Justin’s First Apology opens a remarkable window into Christian worship before imperial favour. On Sunday, the now (arguably) Christian Sabbath, believers gathered from town and countryside. The apostles’ memoirs or the prophets were read; the presiding minister instructed the congregation; the people prayed; and bread, wine, and water were brought for thanksgiving and distribution. Deacons carried a portion to those absent. Justin himself, linked Sunday both with creation and with Christ’s resurrection. [3, ch. 67]
Baptism was connected with repentance, forgiveness, new birth, and a commitment to live according to Christ’s teaching. The Eucharist was not an unrestricted social meal: participants had to accept Christian teaching, receive baptism, and live as Christ commanded. Justin explicitly denied that Christians received ordinary bread and drink, relating the Eucharist to the flesh and blood of the incarnate Jesus. These are substantial sacramental claims, even though later explanations of Christ’s presence should not simply be retrofitted into his language. [3, chs. 61, 65–66]
The same account describes voluntary gifts for orphans, widows, the sick, prisoners, strangers, and anyone in need – Theology reached the collection basket. The Church’s confession of the Creator and Saviour expressed itself in concrete care for people whose lives were precarious. In Justin’s presentation, worship and mercy were not competing programmes: they were dimensions of the same communal allegiance. [3, ch. 67]
6 | Discipleship: The Life Must Match the Name
Justin found Christian courage persuasive before he became a Christian. While attracted to Plato, he heard accusations of Christian depravity but saw believers face death without surrendering their faith. Their willingness to lose the pleasures they were supposedly pursuing made the accusations implausible to him. The argument was not a proof that every Christian was innocent. It was evidence that the caricature did not explain what he witnessed. [4, ch. 12]
He also described converts abandoning greed, sexual wrongdoing, magic, and ethnic hatred. Those who had valued wealth now shared; those divided by hostility now lived together and prayed for their enemies. These are apologetic claims from a committed advocate, not a comprehensive survey. They nevertheless establish the moral shape of the Christianity Justin wanted to defend. [3, chs. 14–16]
He denied that verbal profession could substitute for obedience. Those who claimed the Christian name while refusing Christ’s teaching did not thereby become faithful disciples. The theological force is uncomfortable and enduring: a convincing defence of the faith must include the character of the people defending it. [3, ch. 16]
7 | Resurrection: Why Death Did Not Have the Last Word
Justin defended the resurrection of the body. Christian hope was not simply the survival of an immaterial soul, nor the final escape of the enlightened from physical existence. He argued that the God who could bring human bodies into being could restore them after dissolution. What seemed impossible to ordinary human powers was not therefore impossible to the Creator. [3, chs. 18–19]
Judgment, too, mattered. Justin believed that neither hidden wrongdoing nor persecuted righteousness escaped God’s notice. Earthly courts could misjudge; the divine tribunal would not. His confidence in the coming judgment helps explain both his demand for justice and his refusal to purchase safety through false confession. [3, chs. 8, 12, 17–19]
This did not make death something Christians should seek for its own sake and he explicitly rejected suicide, grounding that rejection in God’s purpose for human life. The distinction matters: martyrdom was fidelity under coercion, not a theological excuse to despise creation or destroy oneself. [4, ch. 4]
8 | Scripture and Israel: A Legacy Requiring Discernment
Justin read Israel’s Scriptures as witnesses to Christ. His Dialogue stages substantial Jewish objections: why did Christians not keep the Mosaic law, and why did they place their hope in a crucified man? His answer insisted that Christians worshipped the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob, not a different deity, and that Christ brought the promised New Covenant. [2, chs. 10–11]
But the argument also has a dark edge. Justin identified Christians as the true spiritual Israel, treated the earlier covenant as superseded, and made sweeping accusations against Jews. In chapters 16–17 he interpreted Jewish suffering as deserved punishment and assigned collective blame. These are anti-Jewish theological polemics, not neutral explanations of history. They must not be repeated uncritically as though admiration for a martyr required assent to every argument he made. [2, chs. 11, 16–17]
The Christian reader can honour Justin’s insistence that Scripture finds its fulfilment in Christ while rejecting contempt towards Jewish people. Historical faithfulness includes recognising where a revered writer’s rhetoric conflicts with the love of enemies he himself defended. [2, ch. 18; 3, chs. 14–16]
9 | Before Rusticus: Confession Under Pressure
Justin asked Rome to live up to its own claims about reason and justice. His First Apology urged the authorities to investigate deeds rather than condemn a name. If Christians committed crimes, let the crimes be proved. If they were innocent, religious hostility was no justification for punishment. Christians paid taxes and prayed for rulers, but worship belonged to God alone. [3, chs. 1–7, 17]
He anticipated danger from opponents, including the Cynic philosopher Crescens. Later testimony associated Crescens with his death, but that connection is uncertain; it should not be turned into a confidently narrated revenge plot. What is much firmer is that around AD 165 Justin and six companions were condemned under the prefect Rusticus. The surviving martyrdom account records their refusal to sacrifice, a sentence of scourging and beheading, and their execution by beheading. [4, ch. 3; 1]
The trial brought his theology into focus. The state could command his body; it could not rightfully command his worship. His refusal was not a denial of civic responsibility but the assertion that civic responsibility has a limit. No earthly authority could become God. [3, ch. 17; 1]
The Enduring Challenge: A Faith That Can Be Examined
Justin’s enduring importance lies in a joined-up Christian vision. The Christ he confessed was the source of truth, the Saviour of sinners, the centre of worship, the teacher of a changed life, and the judge before whom earthly power would answer. His philosophical arguments and his martyrdom were not separate achievements. They expressed the same allegiance. [1; 3, chs. 8, 13–19; 4, chs. 6, 13]
He did not bequeath a flawless system. His theology bears the marks of its age, and his anti-Jewish arguments demand criticism. But he left a formidable challenge to comfortable religion: let your beliefs face examination, let your conduct bear witness, let your worship order your loyalties, and do not call expediency truth. This is a theological reading of his example, not a claim that every later Christian tradition reproduces his formulations.
Rome could silence the teacher. It could not make him say that Caesar’s gods were worthy of his worship. The philosopher who had asked how to know God reached the end of his life answering a harder question: whom would he obey? [1]
Compiled and Written by Disciplesplanet
References
[1] Lebreton, J. (1910). St. Justin Martyr. In The Catholic encyclopedia (Vol. 8). Robert Appleton Company. New Advent. https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/08580c.htm
[2] Justin Martyr. (1885a). Dialogue with Trypho (M. Dods & G. Reith, Trans.). In A. Roberts, J. Donaldson, & A. C. Coxe (Eds.), Ante-Nicene Fathers (Vol. 1). Christian Literature Publishing Company. New Advent. https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/0128.htm (Original work published ca. 160)
[3] Justin Martyr. (1885b). The first apology (M. Dods & G. Reith, Trans.). In A. Roberts, J. Donaldson, & A. C. Coxe (Eds.), Ante-Nicene Fathers (Vol. 1). Christian Literature Publishing Company. New Advent. https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/0126.htm (Original work published ca. 155)
[4] Justin Martyr. (1885c). The second apology (M. Dods & G. Reith, Trans.). In A. Roberts, J. Donaldson, & A. C. Coxe (Eds.), Ante-Nicene Fathers (Vol. 1). Christian Literature Publishing Company. New Advent. https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/0127.htm (Original work published ca. 155)
Theology of the Protected?
“God healed the world once and for all on a hilltop through his own incarnate brokenness. Now the world that we have seen can be healed only by our incarnate brokenness. Jeremiah’s suffering stirs an old irreconcilable truth: When we get self-important, God often gets quiet. It is not the prevalence of people’s words that trouble the prophet. It is the absence of the words of God. In the absence of pain, the intensity of our devotion is lost. Solzhenitsyn said, “If there are no real writers in the West, this must be the reason: There is no real pain in the West.” We are drowning in the cream of utopia. Few real writers? Perhaps few real Christians for the same reason, Jeremiah was caught in the crisis of the war that was destroying his beloved home-land. Jeremiahs lived in times that made him rich with wounds that only God could heal.
What do unwounded servants do? They become arrogant, join country clubs, sell out to middle-class mediocrity, or become fox-hunting Christians. They may even tend toward liberalism, because only the protected have the privilege of making theology a discussion; the endangered cling to it and weep. Liberalism always comes from people with too little need for God.”
Professor Calvin Miller – “Into the depths of God.”
Father Alexander Men (Priest, Activist, Martyr)
“Often what passes for Orthodoxy or another Christian confession is simply natural religiosity which, in its own right, is a kind of opium of the people. It functions as a sort of spiritual anaesthetic, it helps a person adjust to his surrounding world, over which one can hang the slogan: ‘Blessed is the one who believes that it is cozy in the world.’ This is all wrong! …Your God is a consuming fire and not a warm hearth, and he is calling you to a place where all sorts of cold winds are blowing, so that what you imagine does not exist…” 1
So goes the opening volley in just one of Father Men’s unapologetic challenges to the Russian, and global Christian on the ever growing comfort culture assuaging version of Christianity.
Father Men could be (and no doubt was) labelled a zealot by many and of course, worse by his detractors and even more scathing were his many enemies. Not that Father Men would see anyone as such, but his Faith in The Creator God within Marxist Russia was more than a ‘sore point’.
In sad reality, Father Men was martyred with an axe on September 9th in 1990. The ‘axe’ is a weapon of vengeance – perhaps even a vendetta – in Russian culture.
For starters, Men was born to a Jewish Mother in the ‘Catacomb’ years of Stalin’s rabid ‘persecution of God’. Being a Christian Jew, would also draw the ire of that long-persecuted community. Even concerns were expressed by the Orthodox church at his heritage and Christianity. Statements like the following in a denomination that had often transacted in ‘icons’ would be at the very least, cringe worthy to the enculturated church attending Russian,
“I find more meaning in the wing of a bird and in the branch of a tree than in five hundred icons. God has given us two books: the Bible and Creation.”
However, his influence was arguably seismic in the oppressive communist state.
Several comparisons and titles (be it reputation based only) were given to this Spiritual activist Priest. He was referred to as the Russian C.S. Lewis due to his apologetic writings, which was an inevitability as his powerful intellect became evident even at 13 years of age when he would pore understandingly over Immanuel Kant’s difficult philosophy. The late academic Sergei Averintsev called him… "The man sent from God to be missionary to the wild tribe of the Soviet intelligentsia." (He is accredited as the key influence in Alexander Solzhenitsyn returning to the church) And perhaps most dangerously, Father Men was referred to as the… “one man antidote to decades of Marxist propaganda!”
The night before he died Father Men spoke to a large gathering of around 600 people. After pointing out that it was absurd to say the world has no meaning (a common refrain of communism) because to say that something had no meaning can only be done by recognizing and judge it by meaning.
To bring that point home he turned to one of his favourite subjects – being a Disciple of The Christ.
“Christ gave it (the world) a completely new sound with the words “as I have loved you;” because he remained with us in this filthy, bloody and sinful world out of self-giving love. For this reason he said that the one who would follow Him must deny himself (not his personality – for that is holy – but his ego of false self-affirmation), give himself up, take up his cross, which is to say his service in suffering and joy, then follow Him.” 2
References
- https://theinnerkingdom.wordpress.com/2010/05/12/on-lukewarm-christianity-by-fr-alexander-men/
- This Day in Christian History, Editors – Curtis & Graves (Christian History Institute)
Failing Forward – The missionary endeavour we rather not talk about?
Allen Francis Gardiner though raised in a Christian home; he gave no time for this foundation during his very successful naval career. In 1822, after a nasty illness, he re-evaluated his life and wrote the following in his journal.
“After years of ingratitude, unbelief, blasphemy and rebellion, have I last been melted? Alas, how slow, how reluctant I have been to admit the heavenly guest who stood knocking without!”
His conversion and surrender saw him harness and redeem his extensive naval expertise and experience for the service of Christian Kingdom Mission.
However, Gardiner's journey was riddled with setbacks, obstacles and hardships, yet his perseverance was extraordinary. Three attempts to establish missionary works in South America all failed, but still he persisted. Sensing opportunities in smaller jurisdictions off the continent including the desolate Falkland Islands, he returned to England and on July 4th 1844, established a small organisation called the Patagonian Missionary Society. He wrote…
“I have made up my mind to go back to South America and leave no stone unturned, no efforted untried, to establish a mission among the aboriginal tribes. While God gives me strength, failure will not daunt me.”
Despite numerous failed expeditions, including his attempts to establish missions among the indigenous peoples of South America, Gardiner's resolve never wavered. Each failure, from the challenges of navigating unfamiliar terrain to the harsh climates and lack of supplies, only seemed to strengthen his determination to carry on. His ultimate sacrifice, losing his life to starvation on Picton Island while waiting for a relief ship that never arrived, is a testament to his unyielding faith and endurance. His story is a poignant reminder of the power of perseverance in the face of overwhelming odds.
Captain Allen Gardiner died without seeing a single soul saved among those for who he was most burdened. But he lit a fire that has never gone out.
Gardiner's story illustrates the resilience of an individually anchored in his Saviours call and faithful promises, even in the face of repeated failures and hardships, he remained steadfast in his mission. It's a testament to the power of conviction and unwavering faith.
Allen’s life calling is a reminder that sometimes, the journey and the effort can be as significant as the outcome.
Sources: